Pages 6 - 7: Pages 10 - 11: Pages 14 - 15: Pages 8 - 9 Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. OUR FORD HATCHETT IS LIVE IN ASHEBORO, WHERE EVER LOPEZ AND HIS PARENTS PICKED UP THE DIOMPL FORD? Lopez said that the principal market the flag as a distraction. Asheboro City Schools. $32,500. Your email address will not be published. , Guilford County Health Department leaders looks at, Family shot in head at Florida home: sheriff, Infants death linked to contaminated breast pump,, Winston-Salem woman is typewriter wordsmith, Man charged with murder after bodies found in NC, Woman arrested after 9 puppies found in trash bag, 4 charged after assault, stabbing in Burl. In light of the data and bits of proof, we'd very much want . Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? He watched one of them with a flag pinned to her stole successfully walk to the podium without interference from the principal. 2023 Asheboro City Schools. BECAUSE I DIDNT EXPECT NONE OF THIS. Working at North Asheboro Middle School. ACS looks forward to having students back on regular schedule Monday, October 3. 1126 South Park Street Asheboro, NC 27203 336-625-5104. The Asheboro Police Department is investigating 10 emails sent to school employees threatening violence against the school. Ever Lpez's family, friends and supporters gathered outside of Asheboro High School Monday afternoon to witness the graduate pick up the diploma he was denied last week. Si vous ne souhaitez pas que nos partenaires et nousmmes utilisions des cookies et vos donnes personnelles pour ces motifs supplmentaires, cliquez sur Refuser tout. Asheboro High School. If needed Monday morning, meals and bus routes will be adjusted and updates will be shared with families. -Establish educator performance elements and evaluate teacher work . We are sure, someday or the other, you must have heard the name of this school in the news or any article. Lot 23 High Meadow Dr, Asheboro, NC 27205. 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. He comes after serving as principal of Morehead High School in Eden for four years. Asheboro City Schools does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, disability or age in its programs and activities and provides equal access to the Boy Scouts and other designated youth groups. ASHEBORO, N.C. Asheboro police said 10 threats have been emailed to Asheboro City Schools and the high school principal after a student said he was denied . Your email address will not be published. Asheboro High School | Asheboro NC Thusly, this was conceivably expressed as the Reason for Asheboro High School Principal Found Dead. We stepped into this world of unbiased reviews in the year 2015. Speaking with the aid of a Spanish interpreter, Margarita Lopez explained the milestone moment for her and her husband, watching her son become the first U.S. high school graduate of their family, was sullied by the denial of his diploma. No one should have to feel what we did," said Margarita Lpez, Ever's mom. "We addressed all the threats and told her were going to be shoulder to shoulder with her if that does not stop because thats not right and we don't condone it. After the news conference Monday, the family visited Crooks to ask for an explanation about how they were treated on Thursday. On this day, second April 2021, the Wilmington Police Department Got a crisis emergency call revealing into a scene at 3304, Tipot Court, roughly 9:05 am. Dec 2017 - Dec 20214 years 1 month. He wasn't trying to hide it. All Rights Reserved. Principal Penny Crooks wants Lopez to apologize for causing a "disruption" during the graduation ceremony, according to the Family. Vous pouvez modifier vos choix tout moment en cliquant sur le lien Tableau de bord sur la vie prive prsent sur nos sites et dans nos applications. As with all graduates, we wish him well and we will continue to serve our community in ways that help all young meet their full potential.". After this incident, much of the evidence came in to report their statements. The official from the branch Of public issues, Jessica Williams, pronounced that they had found David Eugene Bostian, expired . Categories. As they left her office, they were surprised to encounter four police officers, and felt humiliated as they were escorted by them out of the building," the release stated.After the news conference Monday, the family visited Crooks to ask for an explanation about how they were treated on Thursday. Meanwhile, another graduating high school student in San Antonio, Texas, endured a similar ordeal over displaying a Mexican flag at her graduation on Saturday. May 27The principal of Clayton's Glendale-Kenly Elementary School resigned Wednesday after he was arrested and charged with felonious . ASHEBORO, N.C. -- The Asheboro High School student who was denied his diploma after the district said he violated the dress code at graduation was able to pick up his diploma Monday. All seniors who attend their commencement ceremony are made aware that breaking these protocols could lead to consequences affecting their participation for the remainder of the ceremony.". Despite our disagreements on discipline and field trips, I felt I gave . 10 Sci-Fi Movies Made in Space that You Must Watch. A principal was escorted off school grounds after he delivered a controversial graduation speech. As of Sunday afternoon, the district's Facebook, Instagram and Twitter pages have been deactivated. Thank you and best wishes! Updated: 11:11 AM EDT June 7, 2021. . It just happened out of nowhere," Ever Lpez said. "It wasn't until he encountered Principal Penny Crooks that he had any sense anyone in the stadium believed he wasn't violating a rule. AHS has a long standing tradition of high standards for our students. "I wasn't trying to break any rules, I was just trying to express how I felt," said Lpez, who still hopes to receive his diploma as soon as today. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. He wasn't trying to hide it.". Lopez was wearing a Mexican flag over his gown, marked as rule-breaking by the principal and was refused. This content is imported from Facebook. Prior to entering the school and meeting with Crooks, Lopez's mother spoke out, saying she and her husband were going to demand an apology as well as their son's diploma. Will you do the same? Seagrove High School - Se Hi Yearbook (Seagrove, NC) Cover. "I felt my heart jump out of my chest and was so proud with such joy thinking that my son worked so hard for this and was able to accomplish it," Ever's mother Margarita Lpez said. Moodys accomplishments with Morehead include increased student attendance and increased graduation rates, according to information from Asheboro City Schools. These cookies do not store any personal information. Asheboro City Schools was established in 1905. Asheboro City Schools officials released a statement Monday, saying, "The graduate picked up his diploma at Asheboro High School As with all graduates, we wish him well and we will continue to serve our community in ways that help all young people meet their full potential.". Student Transfer Window NOW OPEN! On Friday, Superintendent of Asheboro City Schools Dr. Aaron Woody, reported that an employee received a threat against the school system in an email. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. "We're hopeful we can come to a solution with the school, and we're hopeful they'll give us an explanation about what happened. A North Carolina high school refused to give a student his diploma Thursday because he wore a Mexican flag over his gown at graduation. Asheboro's Collegiate Collaborators are a group of AHS alumni who volunteered time during their winter break to work with students on Biology EOC preparation. ASHEBORO Dr. Ryan Moody will start his job as the new principal of Asheboro High School in mid-July. Coach Nance led our boys to the first undefeated conference championship since 1976. >> AND THE ENTIRE LOPEZ FAMILY MADE IT CLEAR, THEY DID NOT CONDONE ANY OF THE THREATS O VIOLENCE. I would like to send out CONGRATULATIONS to the AHS Wrestling Team for capturing their 4th consecutive Mid Piedmont Conference Wrestling Championship last Friday night against Montgomery Central. Hopefully, it does change," he said. Ever Lopez said that Crooks was open to the idea of changing the graduation dress code. However, there is no clarity and hence we could not specify as to why. And LaGuardia is one that, in his opinion, works. AN ASHEBORO HIGH SCHOOL STUDT RECEIVED HIS DIPLOMA TODAY. 2023, Hearst Television Inc. on behalf of WXII-TV. . "And all we do here is love and support, you know, and to all those who did that, it's just shame. I'm just representing where I came from," Lopez, 18, told WXII 12 News on Friday.In a statement released by Asheboro City Schools late Friday afternoon, a spokesperson said the incident had been "misrepresented across a number of social media platforms" following the ceremony. Hearst Television participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. All Rights Reserved. THEY MEAN THE WORLD TOE. Ever. Sherri Hall and Jamie Armfield are principal and assistant principal there and both work well with others, have helpful suggestions, and are encouraging . Moodys hiring was announced last week. Stagg High School Principal Ben Nakamura Meza said Nakamura was walked off campus for his and the general public's safety. Skip to content February 2, 2023 Ever Lopez, 18, was given his diploma after he and his parents met with Asheboro High School principal Penny Crooks, who scolded him on Thursday over walking across the graduation stage in what she described as a violation of the commencement ceremony dress code. Ever was sure to thank both of his parents for their support. "As Ever walked to the podium, the release says he passed teachers who gave him a thumbs-up, and Dr. Aaron Woody, superintendent, gave him a fist-bump and a pat on the back. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google. After the 1990s, the school made many changes and added some facilities like gymnasium and other sports and changed the location to Park Street. "One thing is the support but threats and all that is not what we want," Ever Lpez said. Lorsque vous utilisez nos sites et applications, nous utilisons des, authentifier les utilisateurs, appliquer des mesures de scurit, empcher les spams et les abus; et. THE DISTRICT SAYS IT WAS ADDRESS CODE. Saatva Mattress Review: Our Pick for the Best Overall Bed of 2023, We Found 12 Cute Planters and Flower Pots That Cost Less Than $25, Here's Where to Watch and Stream Marvel's 'Ant Man and the Wasp: Quantumania' Online. The school has also recorded many Nobel alumnis namely Elizabeth Lail, Joe Spinks, Randy Henderson, Lane Caudell & John Quinn. Educational Services & Schools. Cindy Corcoran and Stephanie Ellis, both in Rockingham County Schools leadership roles, also expressed appreciation for Moodys service to the high school. ACS Social Media Public Comment Guidelines, Links For Scholarships, Financial Aid and Graduation, Lose Control, Lose Your License Guidelines, Collegiate Collaborators Work With Biology Students. "There is no mention of flags or references to racial/ethnic identity being prohibited in the graduation bulletin, the student handbook or code of conduct," the release said. . AHS has long celebrated and embraced a diverse student body and will continue to work on behalf of all students. Eric Gee, Assistant Principal. "We want to make sure this doesn't happen to other kids in the future. 1126 South Park Street Asheboro, NC 27203 336-625-5104. Advertisement Police are investigating where the. Fox Ridge Rd, Asheboro, NC 27205 was recently sold on 01-10-2023 for $453,500. Asheboro School is one of the most renowned schools in Asheboro, North Carolina, proudly graduating its first batch in 1950. 3101 Industrial Drive, Suite 105 We made it you know, but its not ending here. Wrapping it Up for Asheboro High School Principal Found Dead On this fine day, 3rd April 2021, the Asheboro High School, United States had its graduation ceremony for the batch of 2021. "I felt so much joy, thinking that my son works so hard for this and was able to accomplish it," she said. The family was joined at the press conference by Siembra NC and the local chapter of the NAACP. , proudly graduating its first batch in 1950. He watched one of them with a flag pinned to her stole successfully walk to the podium without interference from the principal. ABC News' Marlene Lenthang, Caroline Guthrie, and Briana Stewart contributed to this report. "I also did it for every parent out there whos an immigrant and comes here to the United States to have a better life, not only for themselves but for their kids and the future grandkids and everybody else, so they can live the dream, the American dream," Saucedo said. As they left her office, they were surprised to encounter four police officers, and felt humiliated as they were escorted by them out of the building," the release stated. denied his diploma for wearing a Mexican flag. Police are investigating where the threats came from. Ever Lopez walked on stage with a Mexican flag draped over his. "It is for this reason that protocols are applied to ensure events, such as graduation, remain dignified without large disruptions such as props, flags, somersaults, cartwheels, or other actions. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. tides equities los angeles does dawn dish soap kill ticks does dawn dish soap kill ticks "And I feel really grateful now that I have it. "I feel real grateful now that I have it because I fought real hard. 1126 South Park Street Asheboro, NC 27203 336-625-5104. Copyright 2023 DODBUZZ All Right Reserved. Your email address will not be published. Police reported three additional threats to Crooks in. Moody's hiring was announced last week. "Im grateful I got what I deserved," Lopez said. Asheboro High School student, Ever Lopez, was denied his diploma by his principal, Penny Crooks, for having a Mexican flag on his back while walking across the stage. Ever Lopez, who is Mexican American, draped a Mexican flag over his gown at Asheboro High School's graduation ceremony in May, prompting the principal to ask him to take the flag off, video. Principal: Ryan Moody: Teaching staff: 77.23 (FTE) Grades: 9-12: Enrollment: 1,294 (2020-2021) Student to teacher ratio: 16.76: Color(s) . The district also said in an earlier statement that it would work with Lopez and his family to resolve the issue. The student body consists of approximately 1,300 students. In the livestream footage of the graduation, a number of students are seen with alterations to their caps, featuring handwritten messages, drawings or flowers. Lot 23 High Meadow Dr, Asheboro, NC 27205. asheboro high school football schedule 2021, Four Best Incorrect Quotes Generator Websites, Ways to Entice a Player Who Gambles Daily on Online Casino Sites. Asheboro High School Unclaimed 1221 South Park Street, Asheboro, NC 27203 Contact info Website 5 /10 GreatSchools Rating 2 reviews 1,300 Students Grades 9-12 5 /10 GreatSchools Summary Rating 5/10 College Readiness average 4/10 Equity below average Last updated: Jul 18, 2022 ACADEMICS College Readiness 5/10 Si vous souhaitez personnaliser vos choix, cliquez sur Grer les paramtres de confidentialit. The latest breaking updates, delivered straight to your email inbox. Lopez and his family said they condemn any violence or threats directed at the school and its employees. "I feel very very grateful because the principal and Asheboro City Schools has agreed and is willing to address this and not only make change for our family, but for other Latinx and African-American communities so that this does not happen again, Margarita Lpez said.The family was joined at the press conference by Siembra NC and the local chapter of the NAACP. dvelopper et amliorer nos produits et services. Asheboro police said more threats were also posted on Facebook and Instagram. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated. You can read more about it here: Also Read Robloxian Highschool Ready Player Two{Nov} Know Event! Asheboro, North Carolina, United States. >> EVER SAYS THE SUPPORT FROM HIS COMMUNITY AND ESPECIALLY HIS PARENTS HAS HELPED HIM ON THIS ROUNDABOUT JOURNEY TO HOLDING A DIPLOMA. Officers with the Wilmington Police. The family also said they discussed the graduation dress code policy she referred to in her meeting with them, and offered to work with her to come up with a new, more inclusive policy, that is more encouraging of kids to express their racial and ethnic identities.Ever left the press conferences and meeting Monday with his diploma in hand, calling it a victory.Marbert said Monday, "We have not been invited to participate in the press conference, nor do we plan to participate. After the interaction with her, he went to the back where his friends were picking up their diplomas, and he was told he would have to call his parents. Dr. Crooks has also taught at . Officers said seven threats were sent to the district's public information officer Leigh Anna Marbert. "I don't see this as a distraction. This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Required fields are marked *. |. ASHEBORO - Dr. Ryan Moody will start his job as the new principal of Asheboro High School in mid-July. He should know his way around. "Its crazy. Today, in this article, we will be letting you know about this school based in the United States. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Ketia Daniel, founder of BHM Cleaning Co., is BestReviews cleaning expert. "The press conference came after Lpez was denied his diploma for wearing a Mexican flag to the school's graduation ceremony.Since video of the incident was posted on social media and gone viral, reactions have become threatening. On Monday, the family also invited supporters to attend a party for Latinx graduates. Police are investigating where the threats came from. Lopez was a student from the same school and was present at the ceremony to receive his graduation certificate. 5,646 were here. Latest Updates. Carrie Huffman, Principal chuffman2@wcpss.net Personal Twitter: @cfhuffman13 After an unsuccessful attempt to take it off, he was handed his diploma holder, which the other students also received. 1221 South Park Street Asheboro NC 27203 (336) 625-6185 (336) 625-9320; Visit Website; Rep/Contact Info. RELATION OFFICERS ARE FOLLOWING UP ON WHERE THE THREATS CAME FROM FOR NOW IN OFFICER HAS BEEN PLACED NEAR C. Reactions to a viral video of an Asheboro High School student being denied his diploma for wearing a Mexican flag to high school graduation have become threatening.Asheboro police said Asheboro City Schools began receiving anonymous threats on Friday, one day after the high school graduation ceremony. Several teachers earned National Board recognition and our Men's Soccer Team was presented with the Asheboro Pride Award from Mayor Smith. Officers said seven threats were sent to the district's public information officer, Leigh Anna Marbert. As of Sunday afternoon, the district's Facebook, Instagram and Twitter pages have been deactivated.Police said an officer was placed in Crooks' neighborhood on Saturday night and another officer would be there Sunday night for her safety. Following the brief press conference, Lopez and his family met for a little more than half an hour with Asheboro High School Principal Penny Crooks. Congratulations to our AHS Wrestling Team and Coach Berrier for finishing 4th as a team at the NCHSAA 3A Midwest Regionals this weekend. The school district superintendent said an employee received a threatening email on Friday that read, "Im gonna shoot up this school if you dont give that young man his diploma," according to the Asheboro Police Department. A spokesperson confirmed the incident to Insider and said . >> EVERS PARENTS ACCOMPANIED HIM INSIDE THE SCHOOL TO MEET WITH PRINCIPAL PENNY CROOKANDS THROUGH A TRANSLATOR EVERS MOTHER SAYS THE PRINCIPAL HAS REAGED TO REEVALUATE THE GRADUATION DRESS CODE. See your Canvas "Class of" Page for your scheduled time. Brittany Roberts, Assistant Principal. The email sent Friday was in response to an incident that occurred Thursday evening at Asheboro High School's graduation. "Following the brief press conference, Lopez and his family met for a little more than half an hour with Asheboro High School Principal Penny Crooks. This name was recently in the news due to an incident that happened days back with some personalities closely linked to the school. We stepped into this world of unbiased reviews in the year 2015. "I don't see this as a distraction. NOTES The unduplicated number of students who are eligible to participate in the Free Lunch and Reduced-Price Lunch Programs under the National School Lunch Act of 1946. In a statement released by Asheboro City Schools late Friday afternoon, a spokesperson said the incident had been "misrepresented across a number of social media platforms" following the ceremony. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. >> ONE THING IS THE SUPPORT BUT THREATS AND ALL THAT IS NOT WH WE WANT. "But at the same time, I'm grateful knowing that I have a community behind me and were all in this together and we will never walk alone.. "It wasn't until he encountered Principal Penny Crooks that he had any sense anyone in the stadium believed he wasn't violating a rule. Steve Wiseman, The Herald-Sun, Durham, N.C. 5/26/2021. "I just gotta represent I did it for my family. Get the Android Weather app from Google Play, Tom Sizemore, Saving Private Ryan actor, dies at, Man hit, killed in W-S on Peters Creek Parkway: police, Prayer against violence event happening in W-S Saturday, Search underway for driver after NC children almost, Potential for damaging winds as storms roll through, WATCH: Snowboarder escapes narrowly avalanche, Storms to sweep through NC, isolated tornado possible, DCs cherry blossoms are confused, arriving early, WWE Monday Night Raw is coming to Greensboro, A sweet tradition at First Presbyterian Church, How the North Carolina Zoo is introducing their lions, NC family bakes bread to help earthquake victims, Bojangles giving away free sausage biscuits on Friday, Swing State with Mark Walker & Odell Cleveland, SCOTUS asks to be briefed about whats going on with, Michael Steele on Marjorie Taylor Greene: Just shut, North Carolina bills aim to protect cultural regalia, Fla. bill would make bloggers register, face fines, Federal workers told to delete TikTok from devices, Thomas Martens, Molly Corbett trial moved to Forsyth, Some fear Nazi banners, power grid attack connected, Video about NC substation attack shared in Md plot, FBI offering $25k for info for NC substation attacks, HPU fires head mens basketball coach G.G. He had the flag either tucked into the side of his pants or draped across his legs, until the time he stood up to walk to the podium, at which point he draped it around his shoulders. "At the end, you know, we came out with it," Lopez said as he emerged from the high school with his diploma. Reactions to a viral video of an Asheboro High School student being denied his diploma for wearing a Mexican flag to high school graduation have become threatening. Graduation is no different. Moody spent part of his youth in Asheboro schools. Asheboro High School is an above average, public school located in ASHEBORO, NC. Even though Ever Lopez has received his diploma, the threats against Principal Penny Crooks and Asheboro High School have not stopped. The Title IX Coordinator has been designated to handle inquiries regarding the non-discrimination policies. 8th Grade Science Teacher (Former Employee) - Asheboro, NC - May 30, 2017. Moodys background also includes several stops in Guilford County Schools. What happened to Asheboro High School Principal? Click here to view the Weekly Announcements. >> YEAH, TO LETHAL. However, Lopez, a student as Asheboro, was refused by the principal his certificate of graduation on the conduct of breaking the dress code. At a press conference Monday, the family of Ever Lpez invited Asheboro City Schools officials to open a dialogue about how the school might create graduation policies that encourage students to express their racial and ethnic identities.Ever Lpez's family, friends and supporters gathered outside of Asheboro High School Monday afternoon to witness the graduate pick up the diploma he was denied last week. Asheboro graduate who was initially denied diploma for wearing Mexican flag, receives diploma and meets with principal, INTERACTIVE RADAR. Hearst Television participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. At a press conference Monday, the family of Ever Lpez invited Asheboro City Schools officials to open a dialogue about how the school might create graduation policies that encourage students to express their racial and ethnic identities. As he approached the principal, he was denied his certificate for breaking the dress code and was told to apologize. As with all graduates, we wish him well and we will continue to serve our community in ways that help all young meet their full potential. "But at the same time, I'm grateful knowing that I have a big community behind me and that we're all in this together, you know, and will never walk alone.". Our staff has been working this weekend to ensure campuses are ready. "In a statement to WXII 12 News, Asheboro City Schools said, "The graduate picked up his diploma at Asheboro High School on Monday, June 7 following a press conference coordinated by Siembra NC. It was observed that he had been Accused of having an unsanctioned romance with a 16-year-old understudy at precisely the same school. The Title IX Coordinator has been designated to handle inquiries regarding the non-discrimination policies. Please help me congratulate Coach Brian Nance for being named this year's Mid Piedmont Conference boys basketball Coach of the Year! In his speech, Nakamura said he would not return to Stagg because. A student wears a Mexican flag over his graduation gown at his graduation ceremony, in an image taken from video provided by graduation attendee Adolfo Hurtado. This website uses cookies to improve your experience. "I didn't expect none of this, you know, it just happened," he said. Find out the height, weight and age of this famous entertainer, Sergio Andrade And Gloria Trevi In Her Life. Lot 24 High Meadow Dr, Asheboro, NC 27205. Asheboro City Schools was established in 1905. Until this day, he was a graduate without a diploma. Three threats were sent to Penny Crooks, the principal of Asheboro High School, who told Lpez the flag draped over his gown was against the dress code and wouldn't hand over his diploma cover. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Banks County Superintendent Dr. Ann . These students represent the graduating classes of '20,'21 & '22 from UNC CH, NCSU, Harvard, Appalachian State, John Hopkins, UNCC & UNCG. No high school Graduate should be embarrassed and denied his accomplishments by a racist xenophobic administrator. It has 1,294 students in grades 9-12 with a student-teacher ratio of 17 to 1. The only reason I could not give a 5 star rating is because the last year I was there I had to deal with a new principal who's philosophy I didn't agree with. ", "They're the ones that really wanted it for me. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. We interviewed our tech expert, Jaime Vazquez, to learn more about accessible smart home devices. Asheboro police investigate threats sent to Asheboro City Schools following graduation, ANYTHING BY CHANCE CALL WINSTON-SALEM POLICE REACTIONS TO A VALIR VIDEO FROM THE ASHEBORO HIGH SCHOOL GRADUATION CEREMONY LAST WEEK HAVE TURNED VIOLENT ASHEBORO POLEIC ARE INVESTIGATING MULTIPLE THREATS SENT TO ASHEBORO CITY SCHOOLS AND PRINCIPAL PENNY CROOKS. >> When people think of probiotics, they probably, Business competition is arising, and you are left behind if you dont know how to. Asheboro High School 1221 S Park St, Asheboro, North Carolina | (336) 625-6185 # 7,878 in National Rankings Overall Score 55.85 /100 quick stats Grades 9-12 Total Enrollment 1,294. When they arrived, they met with Principal Crooks in her office, and she declined to let them take his diploma, telling them they should come back the next day, although it was not clear to them why.