Dimples On Side Of Eyes, The Station Nightclub Fire Documentary, Willy Adames Contract, Viper Cobra Bass Boats, Courtney Turner Wipeout, Articles W

Son Gncelleme : 26 ubat 2023 - 6:36. Christina told Jamie that he did exactly what he said he was going to do. She was caught in the fire and died trying to save them. John and Evelyn were blessed with four children, two of which are brothers and one of which is a sister. Prior to her death, Beth became nervous on her horse, causing her horse to spook leading to Evelyns horse to spook too. BEth dutton. He was a very wise and compassionate man, and he passed down his values to his son. Instead of comforting or reassuring Beth, Evelyn immediately blames Beth for spooking her horse due to Beth's handling (or lack thereof) of her horse. John and Evelyn had four kids. BETH DUTTON. Yellowstone: How Beths Mother Had a Negative Impact on Her Decisions. He served as a livestock agent and was set to take over the ranch for his father, John Dutton III. Monica Long was married to Kayce and they had a son named Tate. She made her aware that she was entering a world dominated by men. She fought back but didnt know what to do. Jamie may be more estranged than ever from the Duttons, but he has something Beth never can a biological child. Beth was able to escape the burning building, but she was left with severe burns on her face. Back then and now, Beth continues to self-medicate with abundant alcohol and cigarette use. They are the eldest son and daughter of the Dutton family, respectively. Why did Jon and Evelyn Dutton adopt Jamie? This is explained in a Yellowstone behind-the-scenes video about Rip that Paramount released on February 1, 2019. It is unclear when or how Beth eventually learned the truth about her condition. Because her mom was an ice-cold, manipulating beeyotch. Evelyn Dutton existed in flashbacks STRICTLY for Beth's story, and no other reason at all. The Yellowstone episode No Good Horses explains what happened to her. Three and a half years ago, wrangler Jimmy Hurdstrom was branded with a red-hot Y iron, but actor Jefferson White remembers it well. Sixth - Tate Dutton. Bruno Amato is the man in the picture on his social media accounts. This event left Beth with a great deal of guilt and trauma, which she repressed for many years. Beth Dutton. Conversely, opting to make it all about the other reason Beth is so mean. She is essentially a witch with future seeing abilities. Evelyn died after being bucked off her horse and crushed, so we only see Evelyn in flashbacks. This is how she dies. For instance, Twitter is covered with words and phrases such as "Beth Dutton for Prez 2024" and "When I grow up, I want to be Beth Dutton." She said he didnt know why she couldnt have children. Evelyn Dutton takes her last breath when John reaches her. However, that doesnt seem to be the case at all. Evelyn passed away a few hours after she did not die immediately. However, her appearances have been relegated to flashbacks as. They spook at things. Chick-fil-As Peach Milkshake: The Perfect Summer Treat! Who is Wilford Brimley and Why Did Yellowstone Pay Tribute to Him? Throughout Yellowstone, John does have romantic relationships with Governor Lynelle Perry and Summer Higgins. Im going to tell you something my mother told me, and youre not going to like it. It is a burning question on so many #yellowstone viewers' minds. This explanation makes sense to me. A past as "broken" as that of the Dutton family would scar anyone for life. Why was Evelyn Dutton so mean to Beth? Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. As a kid, Beth had a relatively normal upbringing though her mom was often hard on her. The showairs Wednesdays at 10 p.m. on Paramount Network. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.Privacy Policy - Affiliate Disclosure. Iheartsev replies with the perfect answer, however. Following her mothers death, Beth starts having a terrible time in life. As for Beth, she gets traumatized by the incident and the harsh dying words of her mother. We're firmly in a hiatus of Dutton family dramathe fifth (super-sized) season of Yellowstone is set to return with more (hopefully not final) episodes this summer, while the new prequel series 1923 is officially coming back for a second seasonbut that doesn't mean our minds aren't still on . Fans of the Yellowstone series are on the edge of their seats as they watch the Dutton family fight to defend their lands. He considers Jamie to be more of a rival than his own son. The main character in the story is named John Dutton. Evelyn was riding a horse that was spooked by Beths nerves. So, how did Evelyn Dutton die? His parents are James and Margaret Dutton. Riggins was the man who hired the militia to attack John, Kayce and Beth, as well as the ranch, but his motives are not known. When Jamie was three months old, John and Evelyn Dutton adopted him. Fans of Yellowstone discuss in a post why John favors Kayce over Jamie. Edvard Munchs The Scream: A Madmans Masterpiece? The details of the accident are not clear, but it seems that Beths horse became spooked and threw her off, causing her mother to be fatally crushed by another horse. One theory suggests that Beth's hatred for Jamie is due to an unhealthy sibling rivalry that dates back to early in their lives. Seventh - Unknown. Even so, their explanation could provide some valuable insight into the reasoning behind Evelyns hatred of her own child. Good question. He has to keep John from finding out that Beth is pregnant and keep John from killing Rip if that truth were to surface. You're hunting. She saw weakness when Beth was cramping, and then learning to ride with her brothers. No wonder Beth is a mess.. Beths unstable emotional state is a result of multiple factors, with her mother being only a piece of the puzzle. She is treating Beth with such disdain because she knows Beth will end up with Rip.. Despite having a chance to clarify that Beths sterility is due to tubal ligation, it seems to have doubled down on the implausible take that Beth had a full hysterectomy. Rips public record was erased for Johns protection. The Lasting Impact of the Council of Trent, Coulomb to Joule: Conversion and Relationship Explained, Couldntve: The Curious Case of A Speech Quirk, The Possibility of Taming a Dinosaur Explored, Could You Please: A Foray Into Politeness. 'Belle de Jour' Movie Review: The Meaning of a 65-Year Opus. I know I did. Let her undo it. Beth becomes traumatized by the experience and her mothers harsh dying words. Eclectic Pop has a spinoff! Dreamer. Im not a horse expert, but ive been around them a fair amount. There are a lot of speculations about her death and her relationship with her family, especially Beth Dutton. Yellowstone: TV series starring Kevin Costner from director/writer Taylor Sheridan. Also, since I can remember shows are based on jacked up families with all kinds of rivalries, families/group that are in conflict, or ensemble casts with individuals who battle one another. Beths mother died in a horseback riding accident when Beth was just six years old. Subscribe to our newsletter for new stories, tips & events. Y:1883 will premiere December 19, 2021 on Paramount+. Theyve Had an Inappropriate Relationship For Months, How Black Creators Can Expand Their Network with LinkedIn. See also What Does The Bible Say About A Godly Mother? H-O-M-E.org is a website that provides information and entertainment to help you live your best life!Our mission is to provide our readers with entertainment and knowledge about their favorite subjects while staying up to date on all the latest trends in popular culture. Its not an advisable emotional strategy at all, but its the reality of the character. It might seem obvious to others. One thing is for sure, John Dutton hasnt moved on after losing his beloved spouse, even after decades have passed since her death. But after being treated like youre weaker long enough, youll start to believe it, too, Evelyn continues. why was evelyn dutton so mean to beth why was evelyn dutton so mean to beth. Evelyn (Gretchen Mol) is the wife of John Dutton III who passed away in a horseback riding accident when her children were young. She has Beth go for help to "undo what she did." Express. So, what have we learned about why Beth is so mean? The show has told us that she pushed Rip away and engaged in every endeavor to do that. Youre not, though. Theyre going to look at you different, see you different, and theyre going to look at you like youre less, like youre somehow weaker today than you were yesterday. Rip Wheeler, fan-favorite cowboy leader and surrogate son to John Dutton, came to the ranch as a teenager in a situation that mirrors Dutton's adopted son Jamie. It's no secret that Beth hates Jamie with a fiery passion, and after he took her to get an abortion at a young age that resulted in her permanent infertility, she may have every right to be. Important to note is that in Season 5, Yellowstone subtly reveals that Jamie is five years older than Beth. She passed away on March 30th, 1997. Her father too lives with this headache & loneliness. Yellowstone TV: Fans Debate Whether Evelyn Dutton Was Too Hard on Beth, re-watching flashbacks with her mother, Evelyn, bottle it up and channel that anger and hurt into strength. I dont agree with it and the scene of falling off the horse could have been a moment Of compassion between mother and daughter but it shows how tough this woman really was. As Yellowstone has moved forward, it has distanced itself from this part of Beths backstory. What Happened to John Duttons Wife, Evelyn Dutton? However, her appearances have been relegated to flashbacks as Johns wife was crushed to death by her horse in a horrific accident in 1997. The Dutton sibling's . Home Entertainment 15 Facts About Evelyn Dutton Yellowstone. They went on to suggest Y:1883 could untap some of the shows hidden symbolism behind the Duttons troubled relationships with one another. She has never been able to get past that. She only makes four appearances in Yellowstone, as she passed away in 1997 when her children were still young. 2023 horseyhooves.com, part of the Hopnetic network. Season 3 of Yellowstone continued with "Cowboys and Dreamers," which aired on Sunday, July 19. She is a former major player at Schwartz & Meyer, one of Montana's leading banks and she is a cut throat business woman. This shows that Evelyn had a great deal of trust in and respect for her daughter, and that Kayce meant a great deal to her. I have to turn you into the man most men will never be. It is known that Beth keeps her sterility from everyone, and it remains the seething secret that understandably destroys her and Jamies relationship forever. GB News host moans as she rips into Meghan and Harry over racism row, GB News host laughs as Ann Widdecome brands woke culture 'dangerous', Michael Parkinson breaks down in tears as he reflects on his career, Yellowstone season 4: Real reason Evelyn hates Beth 'exposed' in spin-off clue, Yellowstone: Beth's mother was killed in a tragic accident, Naga Munchetty shut down by MP in Afghan evacuation debate, Yellowstone: Season four could feature more insight into Beth's past, Yellowstone: Tim McGraw and Faith Hill will star in the new spin-off, Money Heist season 5 theories: Rios death sealed in throwback clue, The Walking Dead: Showrunner opens up on dark final season, Below Decks Captain Lee addresses season 9 disappearance, GMB fury as Marine Commando in tears after being 'cut off' in Kabul, BBC host apologises as guest breaks down over Afghanistan crisis. and Im sorry in advance for doing it. Beth's scars may have faded even more by the time the recently confirmed season five comes around, but they will always be there to remind viewers of her traumatic journey so far. How Helen Keller Overcame the Barriers To Speech, Clocktane Octane Skin: Embodying a Timeless Style, Aldor vs. Scryers: Rogues Guide to Shattrath City, The Babyface Brothers Musical Legacy: Kevon, Melvin, and Kenneth. The late Evelyn has an important talk with Beth that shapes her daughter forever. Its a life choice many are familiar with. Her horse got spooked and landed on her. Her family treats this as Beth being Beth instead of trying to help her or seek deeper answers as to why she is seeking to self-medicate. When Beths riding scares the horse, it has a domino effect. Its not an excuse, but I was just a better father when she was with me.. But he will be mad at Jamie. Why did she even blame her for falling off? Fan Mi-Ofelia takes it a step further by noting they couldnt stand Evelyn from the very beginning and had no empathy for her when she fell off her horse. Though, there are some who are excellent at being abusive behind closed doors and different when others are observing. Lucille Ball did this because she wanted an image of a tough broad and don't be messin' with her. Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. ah, snowflakes isnt just a this generation meme then. But other fans seem to think that maybe theres more to the story we just dont know. Her small yet impactful role in the modern Western drama has invariably shown her being tough and callous towards teenage Beth (Kylie Rogers). 1 views . In one episode, during Evelyns death anniversary, Beth, struggling to cope, bathed in a trough and drank champagne to wash away her guilt. Yellowstone Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. When Beths riding scares the horse, it has a domino effect. Evelyn has briefly appeared throughout the series as a cold-hearted parent to her and John Duttons (Kevin Costner) only daughter. After his wife and son have had traumatic moments at the ranch, Kayce decides to move his family away. The self-described "tornado . A past as broken as that of the Dutton family would scar anyone for life. When she falls, Kayce stays by Evelyns side while Beth rushes off to call for help. Her death had a profound impact on her children and continues to haunt them years later. I Lov this series Yellowstone its actresses & actors! In contrast to the Duttons Salem origins, they continued, ranch manager Rip Wheeler (Cole Hauser) could also have some surprising roots. Yes it really does explain beth, but how could Kevin Costner marry someone so cold? They were raised on the same ranch. Her mother passed away when she was young. It obviously wasnt the warmest or cuddliest of moms but I think she was taking care of Beth the best she knew how, maybe how she was raised? Before the tragic incident, Beth was nervous while on her horse, causing it to get spooked. Now because of that, Evelyn says she'll be harder on her so that she can turn Beth into something that most men will never be. steve russell obituary albany ga; padres scout team 2025; grew wildly out of control crossword; Published by on February 19, 2023. In a post paying tribute to Mols performance in the series, user klaise1 asked: Why does she hate Beth? Costner has seven children, but not Reilly. She played the role of Mikayla in the Disney XD sitcom Pair of Kings. Now, he is too Evelyn Dutton (Gretchen Mol) #Yellowstone pic.twitter.com/P4Pqjg9yXf. Her small yet impactful role in the modern Western drama has invariably shown her being tough and callous towards teenage Beth (Kylie Rogers). I think people narrow Evelyn Dutton down to just Beth, and there is clearly a much bigger story then that. Beth is mean due to a mixture of many tragic layers, further amplified by her ongoing fury regarding her most unquenched desire. I remember there was a video interview of Gretchen talking about it but I havent had luck finding it. When her mother, Evelyn, played by Gretchen Mol, goes upstairs to check on her, she finds a sobbing Beth on the bathroom floor suffering from cramps after experiencing her first period. Lee Dutton. No wonder Beth is a mess. Yellowstone fans are coming to the Dutton daughters defense after re-watching flashbacks with her mother, Evelyn. The real reason for Beths hatred towards her brother is revealed in the third season of the show. Why is John Dutton's one (and only) daughter, Beth Dutton, so mean? Yeah but Beth had zero confidence riding the horse. She made her aware that she was entering a world dominated by men. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. No, Kayce Dutton is not adopted. And Beth has clearly made the choice to bottle it up and channel that anger and hurt into strength. I mean come on even moms love their sons. That scene brought to mind that when we were kids, my 6 year old sister was on a Male horse that ran between a female horse who was spooked and tethered to a post in an arena. She wasnt strong enough in the horse to lead it confidently. Evelyn Dutton died after getting crushed by her horse after the horse got frightened and both fell over. According to the Redditor, their father was Dirk. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. It was the best gift she ever gave me.. Our readers support us. Evelyn is a comforting mother as Beth sits in the bathtub, but she has some more tough words of wisdom for her daughter. totino's snack mix discontinued; Jamies real father is a man namedGarrett Randall, who was adopted by John. Beth tells Rip about Jamie orchestrating his sisters abortion at a Native American free clinic, even though he knew but didnt tell his sister that it meant she wouldnt be able to have a family when she was ready. I also knew a girl our age then who was killed when she accidentally dropped the reins and her horse tripped on them, threw her and landed on top of her. Now, an extreme event like that is just that, a freak event. I love how people think that word entitles them to absolution from the people whose lives they ruin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". 'The Next 365 Days' Book Vs. Movie Ending: How Different Is It? Not as soon or as certainly as fans once thought. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. Evelyn was known for being a tough mother, especially to Beth. Yellowstone Season 2. Naturally, fans of the show have wondered why Beth remains hostile towards her brother. And while fans seem to have it figured out, we know that Beth was also traumatized by her experience with an abortion as a teen. The girl with the baby in Yellowstone was Christina (Katherine Cunningham), Jamies sometime-lover in Season 2. Rips bloodline of the, In Old Norse, seir [is] a type of magic practised in Norse society during the Late Scandinavian Iron Age., The practice of seir is believed to be a form of magic relating to both the telling and shaping of the future. Thankyou. It turns out she was hard on her because she wanted to toughen her up. Let her undo it. While Beth managed to find and bring her father to the scene, they were too late. In a Reddit thread discussing the topic, one fan poses that Mama Dutton is CRAZY. If you recall, theres a moment from the first season when teenage Beth is riding a horse timidly alongside Kayce and her mom. This momentous life event caused Beth to grow up resenting Jamie - who didn't tell her in the process of her abortion that she was also being sterilized. Beth has accordingly exhibited her mothers knack for unvarnished truths. Before their conversation, Beths behavior is timid and a far cry from the tough-as-nails, grown-up mean girl she is today. As most Yellowstone fans know, Evelyn was tough on Beth during her childhood. Lucille Ball told everyone in Hollywood, when she first arrived, that she was from Butte, Montana. Categories . However, she may have been closer to Kayce than any of her other children, as she was very honest with her and did not shy away from telling her the truth, even if it was difficult. Why does Beth hate Jamie: Fan theories. What is the reason for Kayce to be branded? About halfway through their meal, John's . Beths final moments with her mother were not filled with forgiveness or comfort. After her mothers death, Beth is desperate for the warmth of a human soul. Karma., But its u/meemf that gets to the core of Beth Dutton, adding I often think she acts so emotionless and distant because she is trying to reject her own emotions and appear unbreakable.. Jamie may have had his moments of revenge, but those stories have all fallen apart. (Not an excuse, I just remember that from those flashbacks).. Jamie is the father of a boy. An experienced horse woman reacting so swiftly to basically blame her own child, knowing she was pretty much going to die because she was broken and miles from help, shes either a crazy person or she actually had real hate in her heart for Beth. The rest of Yellowstone Season 5 could have the answer to that and if Beth can soften her mean streak. Copyright 2023 Country Thang Daily, all rights reserved. I am re-watching Season 1, and when we are introduced to Evelyn Dutton (John's wife), she is downright hostile to Beth (horse riding scene). 'The Father Who Moves Mountains' Ending, Explained: Let's Discuss, 'Mystery 101' Update: Why I'm Worried About The Next Movie, 'Money Heist' Series Ending, Explained: How Season 5 Finished It All. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Throughout Yellowstone, Beth struggles to deal with the death of her mother. However, fans have another outlook on the relationship. I mean she was the adult, Ok i am trying to apply logic when i dont know the rules but ?? That's what Evelyn was trying to teach Beth, to be tough as nails. All those boys you used to outrun and outwrestle, thats all done, Evelyn (Gretchen Mol) says after a young Beth starts her period in this EXCLUSIVE preview of a Yellowstone flashback scene from the Aug. 8 episode. Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. Maybe there was real hate. A Look at Kelsey Asbille and Her Role as Monica On Yellowstone. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. It was revealed in season one that their mother Evelyn Dutton had fallen off a horse while riding with Kayce and Beth. Beth clearly carries guilt and rage-against-the-world as an adult, but I was surprised I guess that Mama Dutton really seemed to hate Beth right off the bat when we're introduced to her. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. Let's recap: In true Dutton fashion, the family John, Beth, and Kayce ended the episode with dinner at the ranch house. At least Beth checked herself somewhat and decided to deal with Rip vs using him and belittling him because of his background. She was out riding with Kayce and Beth when her horse spooked and fell on her. Second - John Dutton Sr. Third - John Dutton Jr. Fourth - John Dutton III. No one other than Monica has dared to dig deeper. After falling off, Evelyn says, while looking at Beth, She did this. So she could succeed in a mans world. You let me flip saddles around horses going breakneck speed. He doesnt know that she was pregnant with his child. Kayce is bound to the ranch because of his branded name. Rip was discovered hiding in a. Kevin has always stated that Evelyn was the love of Johns life and even created a song just for her on his Tales from the Yellowstone album, so clearly there was a very deep love and her loss impacted them all very deeply. DON'T MISS:Money Heist season 5 theories: Rios death sealed in throwback clue[THEORY]The Walking Dead: Showrunner opens up on dark final season[INTERVIEW]Below Decks Captain Lee addresses season 9 disappearance[INSIGHT]. John was close to Jamies birth mother and he was the father of Jamie. I like the show, but the way they hide characters motivations from the audience for years is a little ridiculous. I think her mom loved her but wanted to make her strong in the town of ranchers and men. Jamies biological father was sent to prison for the murder of his mother. 6666 Ranch: Why Yellowstones Four Sixes Ranch is a Legendary Place. Press J to jump to the feed. four monks white distilled vinegar sds. ---- Yellowstone has not even allowed Beth to express how she felt beyond her righteous anger over being infertile. Jamie is the one who leads her back to her. For all of Beths worship of her father, John Dutton is not (nor has he ever been) known for Danny Tanner-level heart-to-hearts. While riding a horse with her mother and brother, Beth's hesitation resulted in her mom landing hard on the ground and getting crushed by one of the animals. And for that, we cant fault Yellowstones writers at all. Costner and Reilly arent related to each other in real life. It was a time when Beth was a skittish young teen with no self-confidence , which irritated her mother Evelyn (Gretchen Mol). Kayce had a son named Tate who was Jamies nephew. Josh Lucas plays the younger version of John Dutton, while Kevin Costner plays the character in present day. There is no reason to believe that Beth underwent hormone replacement therapy. Who is Melanie Olmstead and Why Did Yellowstone Honor Her? My best guess is and I've said it before perhaps Evelyn and John only wanted boys instead of girls, and Evelyn resented having Beth. While working as an actress in Los Angeles, Reilly said she would visit places like Montana, Colorado . She also had 3 sons, and a husband, and there's no indication at all that they didn't feel loved by her. Which is what I think Evelyn had to do herself. No wonder, indeed. A horse is only scared of what youre scared of youre scared of everything. She and John also adopted Jamie after his father killed his mother when he was young. She lost respect for him after he agreed to the surgery. He is the biological son of John Dutton. Unfortunately, details about the upcoming series are sparse, so this fans claims the Duttons originally hailed from the Salem of the infamous witch trials are currently unsubstantiated. This has huge implications. Beth is noticeably terrified of the animal. My grandpa insisted immediately she get right back on her horse, because in his crazy mind, her fear would not be conquered immediately and she would never ride again. A longstanding sibling . Evelyn has briefly appeared throughout the series as a cold-hearted parent to her and John Dutton's (Kevin Costner) only daughter. , Money Heist is over. Her mother discovers shes just started her period for the first time and goes to comfort her. Summary: Evelyn Dutton was John Dutton's wife and mother of Lee, Jamie, Beth and Kayce. Evelyn . Beth went to get help while a young Kayce tried everything . It does not store any personal data. "But after being treated like you're weaker long enough, you'll start to. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. No, Jamies mother was not John Duttons sister. His time on the hit drama came to an emotional end when he was killed by Jamie after Beth blackmailed him. The show has plenty of enigmatic characters, and one that has fans debating is Evelyn Dutton, John Duttons wife. Evelyn Dutton took her last breath when John finally reached her. As a result, Evelyns horse also got spooked, resulting in her death. John Duttons wife Evelyn Dutton died in a horseback riding accident on March 30, 1997. The death of John Duttons oldest son, Lee, was captured in the first episode of the new series. As much as Yellowstone Season 5 sees Beth wrestle with her demons, it also deals Beth her harshest blow. Evelyn says that everything will change for Beth starting that day. Fans will have to wait and see if any more flashbacks explain their strained relationship any further, but a new theory has proposed the upcoming Yellowstone prequel could also reveal more. We just watch the show from their perspective. She seemed compassionate to her at Xmas and warned her after her first period she was going to have be hard on her. It was all that was needed for a touching moment in the finale when Beth and Rip got married. Evelyns monologue arguably sets in Beths mind that it is her against the world. We owe you nothing. why does kayce dutton have a brand. cosmetology continuing education classes near me; tracy and peter palandjian; raspberry roll maneuver; judge jaclyn medina bergen county; hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy sirius cybernetics corporation; Yellowstone plot hole: Why doesn't the Dutton's home have security? Its safe to say that her mothers passing and coldness towards her during her death have left a lasting trauma on Beth. Jamie met his child for the first time. This rather outlandish theory proposes Evelyn harboured secret feelings for Beths intermittent boyfriend and Johns surrogate son, Rip. This momentous life event caused Beth to grow up resenting Jamie who didnt tell her in the process of her abortion that she was also being sterilized. Maybe it was the writers fault, thats what I assume, but that scene did not fit with Evelyns previous dealings with Beth, they add.