Illegal Discriminatory Restrictions Section 718.112(1)(c), F.S., (SB 630, Page 16). In Aquarian Foundation v. Sholom House, 448 So.2d 1166 (Fla. 3d DCA 1984), Florida's Third District Court of Appeal considered the validity of a condominium association's transfer restrictions . Phone: (239) 542-3148 In Barnett and Klein v. The President of Palm Beach, a Condominium, an owner recovered damages for tortious interference with a contractual relationship when the association denied his effort to rent relying on a rule adopted by the board instead of a limitation in the declaration. 1995); U.S. v. Weiss, 847 F. Supp. This protective measure is deemed to enable the association to exercise some level of control as to the individuals that may reside in a community without unreasonably limiting the owners right to sell or lease the property. Note: Senate Bill 56, Senate Bill 602 and Senate Bill 630 have been signed by the Governor, so the changes are law effective July 1, 2021. The purpose for an Association to require a security deposit from a renter is to protect against damages to the common elements or association property. The Fair Housing Act includes familial status (children) as a protected class. We can also develop the exact language that should be used for their implementation and any amendments to the governing documents, and many of us are also familiar with new online tools that help to facilitate votes of the entire membership as required for such amendments. The prospective owner in the latter case went to court and the judge ruled insisting on tax returns was overreaching and unenforceable. In that case, the purchaser was African American and established that he was denied approval because of his race. I am not so sure that is law in Florida, since there could be very good reasons to disapprove a buyer that should not trigger for purchase by the association. accounts, the history behind an article. As of this writing, Senate Bill 1966 has not yet been presented to the Governor. (b) Before changing the method of delivery for any invoice for assessments or a statement of account, the association must deliver a written notice of such change to the unit owners at least 30 days before it sends the invoice for assessments or the statement of account by the new delivery method. It also provides that condominium associations may charge a fee for approval of leases or sales, as long as the fee is provided in the declaration, articles or bylaws. HOME; . Conflicts between Chapter 718, Condominium Act, and Chapter 617, Florida Not for Profit Corporation Act (SB 602, Page 16). A note to the reader: This article is intended to provide general information and is not intended to be a substitute for competent legal advice. seq., is similar to the Homeowners' Association Act (HAA), except that it applies to condominium associations rather than homeowners' associations.. So, it is possible that the rule is valid, but you should first have the Declaration and the rule analyzed by a licensed Florida attorney to determine whether the authority is properly vested in the board. The condominium association may establish a maximum number of rental units within the project. The period of time the condominium association must wait prior to foreclosing a claim of lien has been increased from 30 days to 45 days after the association gives written notice to the unit owner of its intention to foreclose the claim of lien. PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK. - A bank has commenced foreclosure proceedings against a unit Owner but not taken possession of the unit - The Condo association has liened the Owner for past due assessments -The condo Owner has declared bankruptcy -The Condo Owner has a renter in the unit & is collecting rent Fort Myers, FL 33901 Some experts have gone so far as to state an association must buy a condominium unit when it refuses to approve a sale. A:This is a good question because the Florida Condominium Act does require that the Board keep minutes of every board meeting, and that minutes are official records that must be made available to owners when requesting access to official records. Addressing any flaws in the Associations tenant application process now may help to prevent or reduce litigation down the road. (d) Clarifies the term emergency to have the same meaning as in Section 252.34(4), F.S., which defines emergency to mean any occurrence, or threat thereof, whether natural, technological, or manmade, in war or in peace, which results or may result in substantial injury or harm to the population or substantial damage to or loss of property.. The tenant was charge at total of $625 in non-refundable fees by Quantum on the Bay, which included . On June 16, 2021, Governor DeSantis signed Florida SB 630, which will become effective on July 1, 2021. Specifically, the Florida Condominium Act and Homeowners Association Act provide that an association's official records must include a statement of the account for each owner designating the due date and amount of each assessment, the amount paid on the account, and the balance due. The only leasing restriction in the associations recorded declaration states that owners are only restricted from renting units for terms of less than thirty days, contradicting the new restriction that the board tried to implement. The law was amended to clarify and expand a developers right to use sales and reservation deposits placed in escrow. Most people believe associations have an inherent right to approve sales or leases, but that is not the case. (b) Authorizes the Board to conduct Board meetings, committee meetings, membership meetings, and elections, in whole or in part, by telephone, real-time videoconferencing, or similar real-time electronic or video communication. Editors note: Attorneys at Goede, Adamczyk, DeBoest & Cross, PLLC, respond to questions about Florida community association law. Fax: (239) 332-2243, 4632 Vincennes Blvd., Suite 101 The association eventually settled the case by paying the former president $550,000 and agreeing to purchase her condominium unit. Is there enough time to conduct the election? The failure to adopt the annual budget a second time is a minor violation and the prior years budget will continue in effect until new a budget is adopted. the association may not allow access to "Information obtained by an association in connection with the approval of the lease, sale, or other transfer of a parcel."8 The Condominium Act provides an additional statutory ground . (Section 718.111(12)(c)1, F.S. of Housing and Community Affairs, 135 S.Ct. However, the association may deny access based on a governmental order or determination, or a public health directive from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, prohibiting access to a unit. The bill modifies certain provisions in the Florida Statutes that impact condominium associations and homeowners associations. Before this new legislation, the only limit on rental restrictions in the Florida Statutes, which pertained to community associations, related to condominium associations; there was no such limitation for homeowners associations. Jacob Epstein is an associate with the Miami-based law firm of Haber Slade, P.A. HOAs sometimes limit what types of equipment can be stored outside your home. Condominium associations only have the authority to impose this additional security deposit requirement on a tenant if the authority is so given in the Declaration. The 2 Midtown condo association charges tenants and buyers $550 dollars in transfer fees. A: When an attorney draws up association documents when a condo building is being built or converted, those documents can become out-of-date over time. This case illustrates just one of the many reasons why it is essential for community associations considering new lease restrictions to work in close consultation with extremely well qualified association attorneys. In the Inclusive Communities Project opinion, Justice Kennedy explained: An important and appropriate means of ensuring that disparate-impact liability is properly limited is to give housing authorities and private developers leeway to state and explain the valid interest served by their policies. For example, prior to the Inclusive Communities Project decision, certain federal Courts found that limiting the number of occupants in a unit can be an acceptable policy under the FHA. Under the Courts decision in Texas Dept. property owned by the association that is not part of the condominium). Brad Sohn, a lawyer representing at least one resident who has filed a lawsuit against the Champlain Towers South Condominium Association, said on Saturday that residents were facing. (Section 718.111(12)(a)11d, F.S. Phone: (239) 334-2195 Forgery of a ballot envelope or voting certificate used in a condominium association election is punishable as provided in s. 831.01, the theft or embezzlement of funds of a condominium association is punishable as provided in s. 812.014, and the destruction of or the refusal to allow inspection or copying of an official record of a condominium . Often times, these directors are disappointed to learn that Florida law and their associations governing documents are not as restrictive as they would like. A few greedy condos, mostly in the Miami area, charged five and even ten times that amount. A recent lawsuit filed by a tenant against a Miami condominium association is claiming excessive application fees were charged, violating the Florida law. We offer legal assistance in all matters of condominium association law, homeowners and community association law, real estate litigations and transactions, residential and commercial closings, and insurance law. . Copyright 2023, Pavese Law Firm. Some declarations and bylaws for Florida communities provide associations with a right of first refusal, enabling them to accept the same terms and conditions for any good-faith lease offer that a unit-owner receives and is willing to accept. Florida community associations typically have the right under their governing documents to regulate and approve leases and tenants. First, Florida Statutes section 720.3055 requires the homeowners association to obtain competitive bids for any contract for the provision of services requiring payment that exceeds 10 percent of . Notice of Member Meetings Section 718.112(2)(d)3, F.S., (SB 630, Page 19). The legislature was apparently aghast and shortly after the Supreme Courts decision amended Floridas Condominium Act. Surfside Attorney at Law at Dania S. Fernandez and Associates, P.A. Please try again. The publication of this article does not create an attorney-client relationship between the reader and Goede, Adamczyk, DeBoest & Cross, or any of our attorneys. 7 Mountain Side Mobile Estates Partnership v. Secretary of Hous. Miami Herald Real Estate Column by Christyne Santisteban: Growing Condo Association Budgets Require Deft Touch by Directors, Property Managers, Community Associations Institutes Condo Safety Initiatives Recognized with Prestigious Public Affairs Council Award, Herald Column by Gary Mars: National Media Focuses on Impact of Floridas New Condo Safety Law on Association Budgets. Conflicts of Interest Section 718.112(2)(p), F.S., (SB 630, Page 29). in accordance with Florida Law, that upon receipt of notice from Sawgrass Villas Condominium Association . Most agree that the financial records for a tenant are almost irrelevant since it is the unit owner who is responsible for paying the association. You have permission to edit this article. Florida Community Association Professionals: Why Condominium Associations Must Carefully Evaluate Their Long-Standing Tenant Approval Policies Florida Today: The Fair Housing Act and Criminal . Complaints against Community Association Manage rs and Firm s can be submitted here. ), (b) The statute now provides that arbitration is binding on the parties if all parties agree to be bound in writing. The investment group appealed and was successful, with the appellate court ruling that the change was a deprivation of property rights. West Palm Beach, FL 33415 (e) Authorizes condominium associations to consult with public health officials when determining whether any portions of the condominium property are unavailable for entry or occupancy. / SB 630 Page 12), 3. Your HOA . He concentrates his practice areas on business litigation, condominium and community association law, construction law, and real estate litigation. Therefore, to ascertain what approval rights the association may have regarding a prospective tenant or purchaser, the association should begin by reviewing its own governing documents. The investment group argued the amendment was a violation of their property rights. 2. Some governing documents give the Board of Directors plenary power to adopt, modify or otherwise change use restrictions. Fax: (561) 471-0522. (c) Authorizes the association to give meeting notices by electronic transmission. If the Declaration provides, for example, only that the owner is required to provide a copy of the lease to the association, the implication is that the Board has no right to approve or deny and that the board only has a right to demand a copy. Ombudsmans Office Section 718.5014, F.S., (SB 630, Page 65). The Association should be prepared to provide this explanation even if the Associations governing documents do not require the Association to do so. Additionally, the Associations governing documents may or may not include the power to accept or reject a tenant for any reason or without having to provide an explanation. Any access is subject to reasonable restrictions adopted by the association. The law has been changed to allow the principal office of the Ombudsman to be located outside of Leon County, Florida. The reason for disapproval must also meet the requirements of statutes. / SB 630, Page 40), 12. Only approve select dog breeds. 2. However, that authority cannot be exercised unreasonably. The owner has requested to review minutes of meetings between the board and its attorney to discuss this litigation. In sum, Florida law does not allow condominium associations to discriminate against someone who is renting a unit in the condominium. Board Candidate Eligibility Section 718.112(2)(d)2, F.S., (SB 1966, Page 39). In contrast, Section 720.306(1)(h), Florida Statutes, will provide that the rental restriction will apply to a parcel owner who acquires title to the parcel after the effective date of the governing document or amendment and to a parcel ownerwho consents, individually or through a representative, to the governing document or amendment. The evaluation would occur at the time the application is filed. may be leased or rented without the approval of the Association. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. If the Bylaws do not specify a timeframe for written notice of a meeting other than an annual meeting, notice must be provided at least 14 continuous days before the meeting. The fee may not be more than $100 per applicant and a husband/wife or parent/dependent child are considered one applicant. The bill modifies certain provisions in the Florida Statutes that impact condominium associations and homeowners' associations. In determining the validity of a condominium association's leasing restrictions, the court in Seagate Condo. and Urban Dev., 56 F.3d 1243 (10th Cir. Some associations believe the financial history of a buyer is important. Documents provided to NPR show the board approved seeking a $15 million line of credit on April 13, 2021. The trial court disagreed and explained the investment group bought knowing unit owners could amend the declaration at any time. A condominium, in Florida, is created by the filing and recording of a Declaration of Condominium. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Becker & Poliakoff is one of Florida's preeminent law firms, and the firm that pioneered Condominium and Homeowners Association law in Florida. It also provides that condominium associations may charge a fee for approval of leases or sales, as long as the fee is provided in the declaration, articles or bylaws. That case started when an investment group bought a condominium and the owners in the condominium later amended the declaration to limit rentals. 2022 FCAP - Florida Community Association Professionals, LLC. If the allegations in the lawsuit hold up in court, the association could be forced to pay the plaintiff unit-owners lost rental income and legal bills. Q:Our condominium association is involved in litigation with one of our owners. Again, the restrictions will not apply to rental restrictions that are in place prior to July 1, 2021. Many associations use a blanket term prohibiting "aggressive" dog breeds. 3. One measure that the courts have determined to be reasonable when disapproving a potential sale of a home or unit is the right of first refusal, which would require an association or its designated representative to step in and consummate the sale or lease of the potential purchaser or tenant who is disapproved. History of nuisance in a previous community or in the subject community. The statute does not actually provide that minutes concerning a board meeting with counsel are exempt, but I would advise my clients to protect those minutes until the litigation is resolved. Ownership of Condominium Website The board has a fiduciary obligation to those in their condominium community to protect the community. 17. Court cases have held that when an association has the unfettered right to disapprove a sale, such unlimited authority can be unenforceable as an unreasonable restriction on the ability of an owner to sell. All Rights Reserved. Don't Threaten. (d) Construction Lien Section 718.121(2), F.S., (SB 630, Page 35). Exterior storage. Client Payment. The law prohibits the use of the escrow funds for marketing or promotional purposes, loan fees and costs, principal and interest on loans, attorney fees, accounting fees, or insurance costs. The law also now provides that a person is delinquent if a payment is not made by the due date as specifically identified in the Declaration of Condominium, Bylaws, or Articles of Incorporation. He can be reached at dpodein@dhaberlaw.com. Serious problems may lead the landlord to seek an eviction without giving the tenant an . To avoid surprises, buyers request condominium associations provide a letter confirming the status of assessments. Transfer Fees/Security Deposits Section 718.112(2)(i), F.S., (SB 630 Page 25), The maximum permissible transfer fee has been increased from $100 to $150. Use the 'Report' link on The preemptive right allowed a sale for 95 percent of the offered price and you signed a third-party contract at $9.7 million, well within the 5 percent tolerance. NOTE: Our Client Portal is Currently Undergoing Maintenance. The installation, repair, or maintenance of an electric vehicle charging station or a natural gas fuel station under this subsection of the statute does not constitute a material alteration or substantial addition to the common elements or association property. Simply stated, the opinion holds that a condominium's governing documents may be amended to ban or restrict a unit owner's right to lease his or her unit, even where the resident . 5. By January 1, 2019, a Condominium Association in Florida with 150 or more units (not including timeshare units) must have an independent website or web-portal owned and operated solely by the Association or operated by a third party provider on behalf of the Association. William G. Morris is the principal of William G. Morris, P.A. Rather, such a decision may be left up solely to the unit owner/landlord. What might those be? Associations often require that prospective tenants submit pages and pages of paperwork, undergo background and credit checks, and pay application fees. Florida laws guarantee these rights to associations, but The Fair Housing Act still applies in regard to race, religion, age, etc. In that case, the purchaser was African American and established that he was denied approval because of his race. (1) If a landlord requires a prospective tenant to complete a rental application before residing in a rental unit, the landlord must complete processing of a rental application submitted by a prospective tenant who is a servicemember, as defined in s. 250.01, within 7 days after submission and must, within that 7-day period, notify the The Condominium Act does not merely address rental limitations. Previously, a developer could use such funds for actual construction, but the escrowed funds may now be used for the actual costs incurred by the developer in construction and development of the condominium property.